Prices may vary upon location and are subject to change without notice.
ALL CATERING ORDERS REQUIRE 72 HOURS NOTICE.
Store Cakes
(some cakes are seasonal – please contact us for our current in store availability)
Cakes may contain wheat flour, soy flour, egg, soy, dairy, soybean oil, palm oil, vegetable oil, canola oil. Call for more ingredient and allergy information.
7" Peanut Butter Cup Cake
Chocolate cake with peanut butter icing and Reese's cups| $19.99 | Feeds 8 people |
Allergy Information:
Contains peanuts
7” Vanilla Raspberry Cake
Three layers of vanilla cake layered with seedless raspberry preserves| $17.99 | Feeds 8 people |
7” Vanilla Birthday Cake
Vanilla cake with vanilla icing and colorful jimmies around the edges| $17.99 | Feeds 8 people |
9" Peanut Butter Tandy Cake
Vanilla cake with peanut butter layer and chocolate layer with peanuts on the side| $17.49 | Feeds 10 people |
Allergy Information:
Contains peanuts
7” Chocolate Sin Cake
Chocolate cake with chocolate icing and chocolate jimmies around the edges| $18.99 | Feeds 8 people |
7” Carrot Cake
Carrot cake with cream cheese icing and carrot cake crumbs around the edges| $19.99 | Feeds 8 people |
7” Tiramisu Cake
Vanilla cake with cream cheese filling and cocoa powder with espresso and chocolate shaving on the side| $22.99 | Feeds 8 people |
7” Cannoli Cake
Vanilla cake with two layers of cannoli filling with crushed cannoli shells around the edges| $22.99 | Feeds 8 people |
7” Italian Rum Cake
Vanilla cake with three layers of chocolate and vanilla Bavarian pudding with vanilla icing with sliced almonds| $21.99 | Feeds 8 people |
Allergy Information:
Contains almonds
7” Cookies n’ Cream Cake
Three layers of chocolate cake layered with an Oreo cookie buttercream topped with Oreo’s| $17.99 | Feeds 8 people |
7” Tuxedo Cake
Mix of both vanilla and chocolate cake with vanilla icing with chocolate and vanilla shavings| $20.99 | Feeds 8 people |
7” Chocolate Caramel Cake
Three layers of chocolate cake layered with caramel and a chocolate buttercream icing then drizzled with caramel| $17.99 | Feeds 8 people |
Custom Cakes
48-72 hour notice for custom cake orders.
Vanilla, Chocolate, Marble, 1/2 Vanilla & 1/2 Chocolate and Chocolate Chip
MORE FLAVORS: Carrot Cake, Strawberry Shortcake (seasonal), Tiramisu, Cannoli, Italian Rum and more! These flavors are offered AT AN ADDITIONAL CHARGE. Please contact us in store for more info and for pricing.CAKE THEMES: Anniversary, Baby Showers, Birthdays, Bridal Showers, Characters, Graduation, Religious and Sports. DecoPac cake designs also available for additional pricing.
CUSTOM ARTWORK: pricing will vary for edible images, hand drawn images, cupcake cakes, cut out shape cakes and more.
TIERED CAKES: $4.00 per person (not including custom artwork)
BELOW PRICING IS OUR STANDARD CAKE PRICING FOR THE CAKE FLAVORS - VANILLA, CHOCOLATE, MARBLE, 1/2 & 1/2 AND CHOCOLATE CHIP. THESE PRICES BELOW DO NOT INCLUDE ADD ONS SUCH AS EDIBLE IMAGES AND MORE. Contact us for more info.
| $28.59 9" Layer | $31.00 10" Layer | $30.79 1/4 Sheet | $45.09 1/2 Sheet | $68.19 Full Sheet |
| Feeds 12 people | Feeds 15 people | Feeds 15 people | Feeds 30 People | Feeds 60 people |
Pies
Pies
ONLY Available Thanksgiving Week:Pecan Pie
Blueberry
| Apple | $15.89 |
| Caramel Apple Walnut | $18.89 |
| Apple Crumb | $15.99 |
| Pumpkin (seasonal) | $18.19 |
| Coconut Custard | $15.19 |
| Cherry | $17.29 |
| Peach | $18.19 |
| Boston Cream | $17.79 |
| Lemon Meringue | $16.99 |
| Chocolate Mousse | $15.69 |
Cheesecakes
Cheesecakes may contain dairy, cheese, eggs. Call for more ingredient and allergy information.
In Store Cheesecakes
| 9" Cheesecake | $21.99 |
| 9" Cheesecake Sampler | $24.49 |
| 9" Cherry Cheesecake | $25.99 |
*February’s 50 Shades of Chocolate Cheesecake
Monthly Cheesecake Specials
| January Tandy Cake | $25.49 |
| February 50 Shades of Chocolate | $25.49 |
| March Chocolate Mousse | $25.49 |
| April Lemon Meringue | $25.49 |
| May Banana Cream | $25.49 |
| June Strawberry | $25.49 |
| July Caramel Pecan | $25.49 |
| August Cinnamon Bun | $25.49 |
| September S'mores | $25.49 |
| October & November Caramel Apple & Pumpkin | $25.49 |
| December Red Velvet | $25.49 |
Cookies/Cookie Trays
Cookies may contain eggs, dairy, gluten, peanut butter and nuts.
Cookies & Assortment Cookie Trays
| Cookies | $15.19/per pound |
| 2lb Tray | $34.99 |
| 3lb Tray | $48.49 |
| 4lb Tray | $63.99 |
| 5lb Tray | $79.49 |
| 6lb Tray | $93.99 |
| 7lb Tray | $109.49 |
| 8lb Tray | $124.99 |
Allergy Information:
Cookies may contain eggs, dairy, gluten, peanut butter and nuts.
Pastries
Cannolis - Plain Shells
Fillings: Ricotta Cheese with Chocolate Chips, Vanilla orChocolate with Chocolate Chips
| Small $1.10/each | Large $2.99/each |
Cannolis - Chocolate Dipped Shells
Fillings: Ricotta Cheese with Chocolate Chips, Vanilla orChocolate with Chocolate Chips
| Small $1.35/each | Large $3.10/each |
Mini Cream Puffs
Light pastry filled with vanilla custard filling.| $.80/each | $8.99/dz |
Allergy Information:
Contains eggs and dairy
Mini Eclairs
Light pastry filled with vanilla custard filling and chocolate topping.| $.90/each | $9.99/dz |
Allergy Information:
Contains eggs and dairy
Sticky Buns
| $7.09 | $8.09 |
| Plain, nuts, raisins or mixed (nuts and raisins) | With cream cheese icing |
Allergy Information:
May contain nuts
Sfogliatelles
| Small $1.89 | Large $2.99 |
Allergy Information:
May contain nuts
DESSERT TRAYS
Breakfast Tray
Includes assorted mini danish, mini tea biscuits and crumb cake| Sm $19.99 25 pieces | Med $39.99 50 pieces | Lg $59.99 75 pieces |
Pastry Assortment Mini Tray
Cheesecakes, Brownies, Cream Puffs, Cupcakes and Eclairs| Sm $31.00 25 Pieces | Med $57.00 50 Pieces | Lg $83.00 75 Pieces |
Cannoli Dip Tray
| $22.99 |
Greek Pastries
Baklava*
Sweet pastry made of layers of filo filled with chopped nuts held together with honey.| *please contact store for pricing |
Allergy Information:
Contains nuts